Buttermilk Handcrafted Food Menu (Updated 2026)

Welcome to Buttermilk Handcrafted Food, a hidden gem nestled in Sarasota, FL. This delightful eatery is renowned for its artisanal approach to breakfast and brunch, showcasing an impressive array of options. Among the highlights is the Espresso Tonic, a refreshing twist on your morning coffee, and their signature Neapolitan delicacies that promise a taste of Italy.

Indulge in their mouthwatering biscuit sandwiches, featuring favorites like Benton's Bacon & Baked Egg and the scrumptious Fried Chicken Sammie. For those seeking something lighter, the Avocado Toast and Chia Bowl are fresh and satisfying choices. Customers rave about the scratch-made quality of each dish, complemented by a welcoming atmosphere and friendly service. Whether you're grabbing breakfast to go or enjoying a quiet moment with a book, Buttermilk promises a deliciously fulfilling experience that leaves a lasting impression.

The menu features a strong emphasis on breakfast and brunch items, with popular dishes including avocado toast, pimento cheese biscuits, and baked egg preparations. Price points predominantly range from $10 to $20, positioning most offerings as moderately priced with extras like specialty milks and additional shots available at a supplemental cost. Bakery items and granola-based dishes suggest options suited for lighter meals or snacks, while signature beverages such as espresso tonic and Neapolitan cater to coffee enthusiasts. Beverage selections extend to teas, juices, and specialty sodas, supporting morning and midday consumption patterns. Overall, the menu is well-aligned with morning to early afternoon dining occasions, focusing on handcrafted, savory, and sweet options within a mid-tier budget range.

Browse Menus Across Florida

View All Menus

Pete's Sweet Treats

6616 Superior Ave, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States

4.7 429 Ratings
₫

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Cacio Italian Bistro

3558 Clark Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States

4.9 61 Ratings
$30–50

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

Palm Avenue Deli

1297 N Palm Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States

4.3 378 Ratings
$20–30

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

MERCI CAFÉ

6112 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States

4.9 416 Ratings
$10–20

Highlights: Espresso · Croissant · Iced Latte

What’s on the Menu?

Full Menu (36)

Coffee (9)

Extras (7)

Teas (6)

Signature (2)

Biscuit Sandwiches (9)

Others (3)

Menu Highlights (9)

Menu Insights & Ordering Tips

Opening Hours

More Restaurants Menus in Florida

VillageWalk Cafe